Pat McAfee Returns to WWE SmackDown
Reaction from the field
Pat McAfee’s return to WWE SmackDown on April 3, 2026, has created a significant ripple effect in the world of professional wrestling, particularly as WrestleMania 42 approaches. His alignment with Randy Orton against Cody Rhodes not only adds a new layer to the ongoing feud but also raises the stakes for the upcoming event, where McAfee has vowed to leave WWE forever if Orton loses.
McAfee’s return, which comes after a hiatus due to extreme exhaustion, was reportedly orchestrated by TKO leadership rather than WWE’s creative team. Sources indicate that the decision was made directly by Ari Emanuel and TKO brass, who believe that McAfee’s star power can help elevate the storyline between Orton and Rhodes. This strategic move aims to boost ticket sales for WrestleMania 42, which has already seen impressive numbers, with over 38,000 tickets sold for night one and 40,000 for night two.
During his return, McAfee turned heel, revealing himself as the mysterious voice directing Orton against Rhodes. This unexpected twist has drawn comparisons from Rhodes, who likened McAfee’s involvement to the infamous moment when Disco Inferno was named the third man in the nWo. Such comparisons highlight the unpredictability that McAfee’s character brings to the match, intensifying the drama leading up to WrestleMania.
As of now, McAfee’s first in-ring appearance since late 2025 has added a fresh dynamic to the rivalry. His dramatic pledge regarding his future in WWE adds an element of uncertainty, making the match between Orton and Rhodes at WrestleMania 42 even more compelling. The storyline is designed to keep fans guessing, as McAfee’s involvement raises questions about the potential outcomes of the match.
Cody Rhodes has publicly responded to McAfee’s return, stating, “What are you gonna do? Fire me? It sure worked out for you the last time.” This comment underscores the tension and animosity that has developed between the two, further fueling interest in the upcoming showdown.
McAfee’s return is not just about personal stakes; it also reflects a broader strategy by TKO leadership to enhance the overall appeal of WrestleMania 42. With ticket sales already strong, McAfee’s involvement is expected to draw even more attention to the event, potentially increasing attendance and viewership.
As WrestleMania 42 approaches, the wrestling community is abuzz with anticipation. Fans are eager to see how McAfee’s return will play out in the ring and what implications it will have for the future of both his career and the ongoing storyline. Details remain unconfirmed regarding any further developments, but the excitement surrounding McAfee’s return is palpable.